After inheriting an old farmhouse on Edgewater Road in Ross County, Ohio, Jennifer Smiley sees it as an opportunity for a fresh start, but becomes enamored with the unfriendly, solitary neighbor with deep, blue eyes and an unsavory history.

In the village of Charm, Ohio, Darla Kurtz's father's responsibility for a fire in which he and five other Amish men lost their lives leaves Darla's family to face community's disapproval, while Lukas must deal with the loss of his father and the new awkwardness between him and Darla.