Athena Spencer must live up to her warrior goddess namesake to protect her family from a killer and save their community from ruin after the powerful Talbot family threatens to raze the shops on Greene Street, resulting in murder.

Eight years ago Abby Knight babysat for a problem teen named Elizabeth and now Elizabeth is back with a new name (Libby) and a whole new life that already belongs to Abby. Libby is even trying to steal Abby's boyfriend Marco until Abby finds herself the accused dupe in a bizarre murder plot.